CSI (no spoilers)
Oct. 21st, 2005 08:11 am(expounding from
suricattus's comments)
That episode was brilliant. As far as I'm concerned, that was the best written and thematically most interesting episode they've ever done, head and shoulders above blatant ratings grabs like the perversion of the week or "Let's Put Nicky in a Box."
It had everything that makes original CSI great IMO:
- A case that wasn't, however respectfully, based on "look at the wierdos." I don't blame CSI for casting their net far into fringe cultures to keep the plotlines moving, and on the whole I think that the scripts treat the members of that fringe with tact and dignity... but still, it became a crutch over the last few seasons.
- A case that allowed the cast to emote without it Really Being All About Them. In the long run, I profoundly don't care about Sarah's relationship issues or Catherine's problems being a working mother or Warrick's impulse marriage or Ecklie's machinations. If I wanted to watch the internal struggles of characters, I'd be watching some gak on the Lifetime channel. We hit the right balance last night; we knew what the characters felt and hoped for in a moment or two, and then we moved on to the case instead of dwelling on their feelings. Feelings scenes all too often have "For Your Emmy Consideration" written all over them. Feh.
- Moments of humanity at the workplace. Although I stick by what I said above, I also miss scenes where the CSIs acted like real people in a real job. That's the crucial element so baldly missing in the spinoffs, and IMO the reason why the spinoffs can never catch up to the original. In previous seasons we've seen side bets, mild bickering, working meals, teasing... all the things that make the characters break from two heroic dimensions into three realistic ones.
- And finally, dancing to the edge of spoilers without tipping over, I really appreciated who they used for their narrator and how they used that character within the plot. That totally worked for me.
![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif)
That episode was brilliant. As far as I'm concerned, that was the best written and thematically most interesting episode they've ever done, head and shoulders above blatant ratings grabs like the perversion of the week or "Let's Put Nicky in a Box."
It had everything that makes original CSI great IMO:
- A case that wasn't, however respectfully, based on "look at the wierdos." I don't blame CSI for casting their net far into fringe cultures to keep the plotlines moving, and on the whole I think that the scripts treat the members of that fringe with tact and dignity... but still, it became a crutch over the last few seasons.
- A case that allowed the cast to emote without it Really Being All About Them. In the long run, I profoundly don't care about Sarah's relationship issues or Catherine's problems being a working mother or Warrick's impulse marriage or Ecklie's machinations. If I wanted to watch the internal struggles of characters, I'd be watching some gak on the Lifetime channel. We hit the right balance last night; we knew what the characters felt and hoped for in a moment or two, and then we moved on to the case instead of dwelling on their feelings. Feelings scenes all too often have "For Your Emmy Consideration" written all over them. Feh.
- Moments of humanity at the workplace. Although I stick by what I said above, I also miss scenes where the CSIs acted like real people in a real job. That's the crucial element so baldly missing in the spinoffs, and IMO the reason why the spinoffs can never catch up to the original. In previous seasons we've seen side bets, mild bickering, working meals, teasing... all the things that make the characters break from two heroic dimensions into three realistic ones.
- And finally, dancing to the edge of spoilers without tipping over, I really appreciated who they used for their narrator and how they used that character within the plot. That totally worked for me.